Paying4Rhystic

Highlights

• 📚Selection

  "A hole in the wall MTG store that carries a wide variety of boosters, singles, and sets. The owner is very helpful and they do giftcards, if you're thinking of gift shopping. :)"

  — Mateo Gutierrez

• 🧠Staff

  "Great variety of cards owner is very organized and relaxed making it a great experience overall would definitely recommend"

  — Jesse Vargas

Map

Hours

• James Quiaoit ★★★★★

  Just stopped by today for the first time to check it out since my LGS is closed Monday. Good selection of singles, plus there's a bunch of older sets too that the owner keeps in stock. My favorite aspect is that he keeps Katana sleeves in stock, which are my favorite type of card sleeve! I'm definitely coming back here, and next time bringing my entire playgroup with me!

  6 months ago

• Aidan Morgan ★★★★★

  Had an absolutely fantastic first visit to the store today! The selection of new and old sealed products and singles is phenomenal along with spectacular prices. The owner Robert was incredibly kind and helpful in answering any questions I had. A must go to spot for all fans of Magic the Gathering. Definitely coming back for more! :)

  8 months ago

• Mateo Gutierrez ★★★★★

  A hole in the wall MTG store that carries a wide variety of boosters, singles, and sets. The owner is very helpful and they do giftcards, if you're thinking of gift shopping. :)

  7 months ago

• Sabrina Fischer ★★★★★

  We’ve searched card shops in Modesto before and this one never came up or at least we didn’t notice. This was our first time going in there and I’m pretty sure my husband is hooked. It’s ALL Magic the Gathering cards. They will have anything you’ll ever want as far as Magic goes. They are super nice and informative. We will be back very soon.

  a year ago

• Rafael Gonzalez ★★★★★

  Robert runs a great card shop, very organized and knowledgeable when it comes to MTG. His shelves are always stocked with the latest sets as well as some of the older ones! Always love visiting his shop. 10/10

  10 months ago

• Jered Dahlgren ★★★★★

  Just found this shop today and wow! I wish I had found it sooner! Amazing collection of singles and a ton of sealed product as well. Robert, the owner, checks prices for singles against TCGPlayer and undercuts the market price by about a buck or 2 which is awesome. Super friendly owner and very welcoming atmosphere. I will 100% be back to this shop for future MTG purchases.

  a year ago

• Jesse Vargas ★★★★★

  Great variety of cards owner is very organized and relaxed making it a great experience overall would definitely recommend

  6 months ago

• Calickal ★★★★★

  Wasn't sure what to get a couple months back for a collector box and ended up getting a dominaria remastered from the owner's recommendation, and it was an amazing choice, great cards and great price! Love the selection for sealed displays. My wife is getting into bloomburrow with me and I recommended she go here too. I'd recommend any MTG players or collectors go here to pick up cards over any other shop in town.

  a year ago