Montasy Comics NYC

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Great spot, friendly staff, single magic cards"

  — Caesar Sanchez

• 📚Selection

  "Really cool store- nice selection of TCG"

  — Andrew O

• 🧠Staff

  "I love this comic store. Highly recommend it"

  — Kevin Rosales

• 🎟️Events

  "Great place to play fnm tons of selection"

  — Tadeus Martyn (PerfectDark64)

• 💵Prices

  "Awesome shop good customer service and good price"

  — Nicholas Berenguel

About this shop

Minimalist store carrying the latest comic books with weekly events & community space for gamers.

Map

Hours

• Jake Katsenko ★★

  Tried to buy a Topps Chrome Hobby box here 2x. They have a good selection of Magic cards that i was buying for my son so figured i would get something for myself as well. Prefer to support small businesses but their cost was more than Dave and Adams had for the same product (not including 5% discount) 2 blocks away so asked for a free pack of hard cases to cover some of the difference. Was told absolutely no each time. Not sure how that makes sense from a business perspective, they lost ~$1600 for $5-10 in hard cases when i was willing to spend more to support a smaller biz. Guess i'm not comi

  4 months ago

• Jaiden Andrews ★★★

  Nice selection, kinda small, it says 2 floors on outside but I only saw one. I’d go back again just because they close a bit later than midtown comics.

  5 months ago

• Michael Riccard ★★★★★

  Had an amazing experience. The staff were helpful for my kids who wanted more Pokemon cards and even threw in some small lunch boxes for free! The kids had a blast looking at all their selection.

  5 months ago

• Liran Tal ★★★★★

  Very kind crew. I went for board games. They didn't have a lot, maybe a dozen, but they had some good choices for a gift. Awesome store highly recommend a visit if you're in the area and loved comics (they have a bit of anime too)

  6 months ago

• Tristan ★★★★★

  Montasy is one of my favorite spots for Gundam TCG locals. The venue is spacious, the staff friendly, and tournaments are run efficiently. The venue has a wide selection of merchandise spanning the majority of card games, and comic books.

  5 months ago

• Computer Tech ★★★★★

  Montasy Comics NYC is an absolute gem for comic book and trading card enthusiasts! I’ve been coming here for years, and every visit brings back that same excitement I felt the first time I walked in. The selection is phenomenal—everything from classic and new comics to an impressive array of trading cards, collectibles, and rare finds. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and genuinely passionate, always ready to chat, offer recommendations, or help track down that hard-to-find item. This store isn’t just a shop—it’s a place that sparks joy, fuels imagination, and makes you feel part of a wel

  8 months ago

• Animon Master ★★★★

  Nice store wide verity of products and have really nice community as well as events that happens the only reason this isn't a 5 star review is I feel like they overprice allot of there pokemon tcg products way above msrp saw some packs there once for $13 depending on the set. And look i know pokemon is the most scalp product but still 13

  6 months ago

• Jason Belcher ★★★

  Traveller from the UK here. Singles are priced okay. Felt they were fair. Sealed is a bit all over the place. $5 for Innistrad Play Booster, not bad. $30 for an Aetherdrift PreRelease, not bad. $34 for Innistrad Remastered Collector Booster - bit over the top. Staff seemed an average amount of polite. However, zero interest/knowledge in the product or helping with advice/anything on top. So a bit of a flat experience. Loads of selection of sealed from the last 12 months. A couple of shelves of singles and some proper nice dual lands in a cabinet. But overall, 3 stars.

  a year ago