Midnight Games LLC

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Nice store with a good selection and really chill staff."

  — Zachary Chambless

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection of retro games and consoles."

  — Justin Cox

• 🧠Staff

  "Nice store with a good selection and really chill staff."

  — Zachary Chambless

• 🎟️Events

  "Walked in here yesterday and found some of the cards i was looking for. Owner was quick about finding what i needed. They are new to the industry but i would definatly give them a shot. Also got invited for a draft so we will see how that plays out."

  — Bryce Edwards

• 💵Prices

  "Expensive but they have everything I needed"

  — John D

Map

Hours

• MARTIAN ★★

  DO NOT SHOP HERE. The only reason I'm not giving 1 star is because their selection of retro games and trading cards is decent. I regularly come here just to look at their Magic The Gathering products. Today I went in and noticed they were selling Spider-Man Welcome decks for $30!! For reference: These are explicitly NOT meant for resale and are supposed to be handed out to new players for FREE to get people into the game. Selling them for money at all is STRICTLY forbidden by Wizards of The Coast and EXTREMELY scummy. Par for the course with this store though. They purchase all their produ

  4 months ago

• John Julian ★★★★★

  They have a pretty nice selection of Magic singles. I didn't get to play Magic due the time of day I was there but it looks like it would be a little too cramped for my anxiety if it were busy. Staff was polite and knowledgeable.

  3 months ago

• Cami Smith ★★★★★

  This game shop has the best atmosphere and amazing employees! Wednesday and Friday night MTG Commander nights are awesome. The pre-release nights are so fun too! They even have great prices on all their merchandise. 10/10 recommend!

  4 months ago

• Landon Potter ★★★

  Cool shop with tons of options and a surprising amount of rare games. When compared to pricecharging or recently sold on eBay, these games are at LEAST 25% overpriced across the board. Otherwise this would be a great shop! Plus they put warranty stickers on the discs of whatever games you buy. SO close to being an awesome shop!

  4 months ago

• Jeff ★

  Stay away from this place, worst deals of any retro gaming store near Denver. At a glance you’ll believe they have an impressive collection, but they clearly order online and then resell 1.5x that from the CiB pricecharting average, even though it’s often NOT CiB at the store. They will not disclose the contents of the case to you unless asked… Feels like they’re often banking on your ignorance around how this stuff is valued. You could find better buy-it-now prices for elusive games on e-bay, not to mention they also put their ugly logo on their discs, which reviewers below have verified can

  4 months ago

• william paugh ★★★★★

  I happened upon this place while driving by, and decided to stop. Glad I did! A hidden treasure of retro games and consoles, if you're into those things this is a great place to stop in the Springs. In a separate room they have a Magic the Gathering area that spacious and well decorated. They also have some collectibles for sale and even some comic books, though I think they could expand their selection of comics a little. I had a good time here and ended up buying a game.

  a year ago

• Chris ★

  I’m writing to inform you of a frustrating experience with your manager. After my wife purchased a game, I returned within the hour to request a refund. I acknowledged your policy, but politely asked if any flexibility could be considered given the timing. The manager refused, which I accepted, but then he told me I shouldn’t have spent the money and gave me attitude. He went on break, and another employee—who was polite—said no refund could be processed without the manager. I waited and returned 45 minutes later, only to have the manager insist sales tax is never refunded. After I explained t

  4 months ago

• Chloe Dieters ★

  Edit: Stickers have spread to all discs, and I cannot in good conscience recommend these guys as I trusted them when they said “oh they can be removed”, and now I’ve had a casualty. My copy of Animal Crossing City Folk has had its label damaged, thank god it’s a DVD and it’s still playable. And ofc they won’t refund you for damage their sticker caused. Yall could’ve used a stamp or something, i doubt the amount of people coming in and returning a swapped disc was truly that catastrophic. They also still have “The Guy Game” lol, and I’ll always dog on a store trying to sell that game hah! Good

  Edited 7 months ago