Wally's Sports Card and Collectibles

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Wally is super friendly and knowledgeable"

  — Megan McGovern

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection of cards and supplies highly recommended"

  — Robert wojak

• 🧠Staff

  "Wally is super friendly and knowledgeable"

  — Megan McGovern

• 💵Prices

  "Great card shop great prices easy to work with"

  — Blake Zovar

Map

Hours

• RJ Savic ★★★★★

  Stopped in to check out the shop on one of my many trips between Madison and Milwaukee. Was looking for sealed product and their inventory was pretty much non-existent. Wally (owner I believe) explained to me that he was waiting on a big restock order and that my timing sucked... I said no problem and turned to leave, but before I could Wally was throwing free packs at me just for stopping in. Ended up buying one of the three sealed boxes he had in stock just because Wally was so friendly and honest. Now, the shop will be a must-stop when passing through J.C. Just goes to show how important

  2 years ago

• James Strom ★★★★★

  One of the best card shops I’ve been to. Great guy who gives a fair deal and knows the value of his cards. Will definitely be back.

  a year ago

• Ryan Yort ★★★★★

  Stopped in for the first time Friday 10/7 and was very pleasantly surprised with the amount of vintage cards and memorabilia of all sports to trading games such as Pokémon. The owner, Wally, was very kind and easy to work with. You can tell he cared about customers from offering beverages to interacting with the children that were there with their parents. I highly recommend giving this gem of Johnson Creek a visit if you’re into cards or just want to talk shop with kind sports enthusiasts! Will definitely be back again!

  3 years ago

• SG ★★★★★

  This is basically everything you want in a local card shop: 1) Very, very nice people: Wally, the owner, is a friendly, approachable, and immediately likable guy. Small shops with specialized merchandise can often be intimidating; not this place. 2) Comfortable atmosphere. Clean, nice display cases, well-organized stock, seating for browsing, etc. 3) Fair prices on a good selection of sealed packs and boxes. I also highly recommend the $1 box, which was on sale and which I subsequently picked through for probably an hour. I live a ways out - about 40 minutes - but I'll be going out of my w

  6 years ago

• Just Jeff ★★★★★

  I almost don’t want to leave a review. I’m worried too many people will be in here when I want to go :). We’re lucky to have good card shops around, but this stands above all the ones I can think of. I’ll drive 30 miles to spend a few bucks more to make sure this store stays. Wally was so helpful and knowledgeable, I wished I could have stayed longer. I’ll plan to stop by whenever I’m able.

  6 years ago

• T Zone ★★

  Is this place even open? I went to the address listed (says it was open today, Sunday, 11-4) no signage for this business on building at all, main entrance to building was locked. 1st picture on Google maps isn’t the property listed, you can see the Johnson Creek water tower in the background, name on business is Johnson Creek Cards and Collectibles? Phone # listed for JCC&C says not in service, phone # for Wally’s went unanswered.

  a year ago

• Ray Murray ★★★★★

  I frequent this hobby shop. Wally (the owner) is always there to greet you with a smile on his face. Very knowledgeable on sports and trading card games. The $1 boxes are always my go to. They also carry a variety of collectable supplies and boxes/ packs of cards from every sport to choose from. Highly recommend going there if you are in the area.

  2 years ago

• Travis Peartree ★★★★★

  Great local card shop. Wally always has a great selection of cards and always giving good deals. Many times I stop in I’m offered a cold soda while I’m browsing the singles boxes. Great selection of card supplies as well. I’d rather drive here then go to overpriced LCC in Oconomowoc.

  2 years ago