Card Shops Finder

The PokeShop Buy Sell Trade

3132 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53222

★★★★☆ 4.1 · 220 reviews
PokémonYu-Gi-Oh! ⚡️Pokémon League 🛡️Grading 🏛️Vintage

Highlights

  • Vibe

    "Fun, inviting, friendly staff, great prices!"

    — Alma Ramirez

  • 📚Selection

    "Friendly employees, good selection to choose from!"

    — josie

  • 🧠Staff

    "Fun, inviting, friendly staff, great prices!"

    — Alma Ramirez

  • 🎟️Events

    "I play thr pokemon league here and its always packed. Great place to buy/sell/trade. Good prices all around. :3"

    — Hollyann Wilson

  • 💵Prices

    "Great products. Great team. Fair pricing."

    — Lue Xiong

Map

Hours

Monday 11 AM–7 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–7 PM
Thursday• today 11 AM–7 PM
Friday 11 AM–7 PM
Saturday 11 AM–7 PM
Sunday Closed

Recent reviews

8 of 220
  • Mike Allen ★★★★★

    Can’t recommend this place enough. Prices are extremely reasonable, trade values are higher than I’ve seen anywhere else, and the owner/employees love what they do which makes the environment there so welcoming. Brought in a few of my childhood doubles and the owner not only gave me a great deal for store credit (like $700 more than another shop) but he threw in a few free packs and stuff. Went in today as a return and got both the SIR charizard and Gold Charizard in the same booster box. The owner was equally excited and happy for me. Great guys and even better prices. 11/10.

    4 months ago

  • Anthony Hadden

    When I first started going here the prices were reasonable. Above MSRP obviously but slightly below market. Now everything is ABOVE market. Sometimes well above. I tried to sell some cards and they ranged from $15-35 cards and the guy said he wasn't interested because they would take to long to resell them. Ended up selling them on Ebay for market in about a week. Wouldnt recommend buying or selling from here anymore. They just see dollar signs when you walk in

    3 months ago

  • Kurtis ★★

    Shop had a really great variety of products but prices were really insane compared to other stores we have been to in the past. I would definitely not recommend selling/trading your cards here, the price I got was fairly low (considering other expenses) While staff was friendly it was very busy and hard to move around the store with people everywhere. Overall, if you’re looking for hard-to-find sealed products, I’d recommend, but other than that this wasn’t the most enjoyable place to find fun Pokemon products.

    4 months ago

  • Korone Time ★★★★★

    I opened a booster bundle of mega evolution and it only had 5 packs instead of the 6. I told the one worker there about this and they gave me a pack on the house. I really appreciate the kind gesture.

    8 months ago

  • Matt R ★★★★★

    Good stock, prices were within reason. Market demand for Pokemon is high and causing higher prices. Pulled a Gold Charizard from Phantasmal Flames from a booster box from this shop today. Will visit shop again. Had a good experience here.

    6 months ago

  • C ★★★

    The store has a decent selection on product. But they charge scalper prices. A booster box of Destined rivals Japanese is selling for 120. Yet Tcgplayer says they are 97. I would like to support local shops. But i cannot justify spending more than what the product is worth.

    9 months ago

  • Stephanie White

    I have been collecting Pokémon cards for a long time. I know what a resealed pack looks like. All of their single packs are resealed. I feel bad for the parents that go there to buy their kiddos cards because I’m sure they don’t know the difference. I WILL NEVER GO HERE AGAIN

    7 months ago

  • Maggie Cagle

    Honestly I thought I would have a good experience with this place based off of the pleasant conversation I had on the phone prior to coming in. Had a horrible experience trying to ask about selling or trading in cards here. When I had initially asked they did not explain that they typically look for extremely high value cards( I'm assuming typically only graded cards too based on there selection in cases, all other cards were tossed in some binders on the side), when I initially asked the employee told me they typically look for trades 5$ and above. I gave them a small binder from my collectio

    a year ago

More shops near Wauwatosa

Board Game Barrister

2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226

★★★★★
4.6 · 414
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

Stevie's SportsCards

2817 N 88th St, Milwaukee, WI 53222

★★★★
3.7 · 3
Sports Cards

The Crimson Guild

8730 W North Ave, Wauwatosa, WI 53226

★★★★★
4.9 · 315
PokémonMagic: The GatheringYu-Gi-Oh!

Collector's Edge Comics | North - Kops Park

7826 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, WI 53222

★★★★
4.4 · 107
Magic: The Gathering 🧠Expert staff 🏠Owner-run

Happy Hobby

7821 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, WI 53222

★★★★
3.5 · 118
Yu-Gi-Oh! 🏛️Vintage 🧠Expert staff

Jeff's Sports, Inc.

14165 W Capitol Dr, Brookfield, WI 53005

★★★★★
4.9 · 111
Sports Cards 🛡️Grading 🏛️Vintage