The Game Cave

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "It's a nice place, and the staff are very friendly."

  — Brad S

• 📚Selection

  "The staff was very helpful and friendly. They have a large selection of MTG cards as well. I would definitely recommend them to my friends."

  — Stephen Guarino

• 🧠Staff

  "It's a nice place, and the staff are very friendly."

  — Brad S

• 💵Prices

  "Very fair prices and the atmosphere is nice. Wonderful spot for MTG"

  — Michael Cranston

Map

Hours

• Chaz Hendrick ★★★★★

  This is the coolest place around. I drove from Rochester just to go there. The man behind the counter that goes by Frankie deserves a massive raise. Charismatic and Knowledgeable even about games that the store does not have.

  3 months ago

• Bill Batson ★

  This store is a mess. The player base is overly emotional and starts arguments over trivial rules calls. People dance during cEDH games like it is a club instead of a competitive environment. Emotional outbursts toward disabled veterans happen without any staff intervention. The space itself is rough. The smell hits you before you sit down. The tables are dirty, the room feels unkept, and the overall aesthetic is gross. It is not a place you go to focus, compete, or enjoy a clean environment. If you want an actual competitive Magic experience or even basic respect, look elsewhere. This shop

  6 months ago

• Timothy V. ★★★★★

  Excellent local gaming store. There is a very welcoming and active MTG community here that has been fostered and cultivated by Frank, the manager of the shop. The shop itself is smaller and focuses on MTG , Yugio, and D&D with singles and sealed products. There are some pokemon products available for sale. There are always pods of games going on that welcome any newcomer to hop in.

  Edited a year ago

• Michael Cranston ★★★★★

  Very fair prices and the atmosphere is nice. Wonderful spot for MTG

  6 months ago

• Daniel Hochstine ★★★

  Has cards and dnd supplies, nothing GW. door says warhammer stock list but it seems like it's not popular in Batavia.

  9 months ago

• kylie ryan ★★★★★

  I was visiting my family and some friends wanted to play D&D I stopped in the Game Cave to pick up some dice and they were so friendly and kind! The store had a lot of people playing games. It looks like a great place to meet friends and pick up gaming supplies.

  a year ago

• John Boyea ★★★★★

  Great place for all your gaming needs and some trading cards

  4 years ago

• Jonathan Thomas ★★★

  They have a nice few people that work there I wish they had more of a selection than just magic, warhammer, and dnd. The casual dragon I would say is more lf the ideal game shop, that place makes me feel like home while The Game Cave is held for tournaments and casual play. Both places are very nice and the either two places such as Batavia or Lockport so I'm kind of in the middle of both those places so when I'm out traveling it's definitely a place I can stop by to finish up some decks I'd be working on. They are a great place to play magic at and host your dnd campaigns to just go out and

  3 years ago