Smitty's Coins and Currency East
80 S Main St, Canandaigua, NY 14424
Highlights
- ✨Vibe
"Great experience. Prices are very fair and staff are friendly. My dad and I bought on whatnot and decided to see the shop in person. I asked to have a coin checked I bought elsewhere for authenticity and they were very accommodating. Picked up a few items as well. Will be back!"
— Brandon G
- 🧠Staff
"Professional and knowledgeable staff. Fair prices! Well worth the drive."
— Alexander Crilly
- 💵Prices
"Professional and knowledgeable staff. Fair prices! Well worth the drive."
— Alexander Crilly
Map
Hours
| Monday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday• today | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–4 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Recent reviews
8 of 65- Christine Perrin ★★★★★
This shop is both honest and professional. It gives you the small town feel when you walk in. Everyone there takes great pride in how they treat their customers. The owner, is extremely knowledgeable and honest. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to add to their collection or make transactions.
4 months ago
- Brandon G ★★★★★
Great experience. Prices are very fair and staff are friendly. My dad and I bought on whatnot and decided to see the shop in person. I asked to have a coin checked I bought elsewhere for authenticity and they were very accommodating. Picked up a few items as well. Will be back!
4 months ago
- Dallas Weart ★★★★★
Smittys has SO much to offer! Whether you are looking for unique currency, sports cards, Pokémon, Magic, One Piece, Lorcana, Digimon, you name it they have it! Better yet Smittys is more than just cards and coins. The atmosphere is very community driven and you can tell they put so much effort into providing their customers with a fun experience. I highly recommend anybody to stop by for their local events or just to shop around! I guarantee you there is something for everybody!
6 months ago
- michael patrick ★★★★★
I've been collecting coins and silver for a little over a year now and Smittys is a great small coin shop that also sells, buys and trades magic the gathering and other cards.(I'm not too knowledgeable about these card games. I went to check out coins and Silver.) I felt very comfortable there with the helpful staff and the no pressure way they do business there. They have a large selection of junk / constitutional (90% and 40%) Silver coins, gold bullion coins, proof sets, collecting supplies and so much more. They also usually have some nice silver and gold bullion. The staff is the nicest
4 years ago
- Gaston d'Orléans ★★★★★
Walking into Smitty's is like finding the fountain of youth. Smitty is passionate about his hobby. It is a real honor to meet someone who is as knowledgeable and forthright as Mr. Smitty. I hope one day I can share my passions and hobbies as keenly and openly as this great man.
10 months ago
- Alexander John ★★★★★
At first I walked in trading my silver eagles, and he bought them a dollar above spot. Also traded my 1819 Half Dollar which was in rough shape. I was going to take the money I got for them, and go, but the variety of coins this guy has is amazing. While browsing, he taught some young kids that came in with their Mom about coins. I came out with a bag of assorted wheat pennies, which had a lot of old dates and S mint marks, BU’s, with some Indian cents too! Also got two morgan silver dollars! A++++ RECOMMEND!
4 years ago
- Brenten Bradley ★★★★★
If I could give more than 5 stars I would. My sister and I made an appointment with Smitty to appraise my late father’s coin collection. He was extremely knowledgeable and completely transparent about what he would pay for our collection and what he would likely sell them for. At the end of the meeting he bought the entire collection at a price we were very happy with. Thank you so much Smitty, I hope to do business with you again soon.
a year ago
- Alexander Crilly ★★★★★
Professional and knowledgeable staff. Fair prices! Well worth the drive.
4 months ago
More shops near Canandaigua
Dork Forest Comics
18 E Main St, Clifton Springs, NY 14432
Two Kings Comics
171 W Main St Unit A, Victor, NY 14564
Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles
256 Main St, Phelps, NY 14532
Collector's Paradise
102 Eastview Mall, Victor, NY 14564