Mt Sterling Baseball Cards

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Great selection, and great prices! The owner is super friendly and very helpful! 10/10"

  — Dustin Hughes

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection, and great prices! The owner is super friendly and very helpful! 10/10"

  — Dustin Hughes

• 🧠Staff

  "This place is a gem. Best cards around. Love the owner."

  — Ian Horn

• 💵Prices

  "Nice man, reasonable prices. Would recommend to collectors."

  — Jennetta Curry

Map

Hours

• Bretten Reese ★★★★★

  45 min drive into this nice little store that is run by the owner (older gentleman) VERY NICE GUY and has TONS of hobby boxes from 2022-2026 & from the past few years available for basketball football & baseball! Basic Card Supplies Available also as needed! Mags. Top loaders. Penny sleeves. Etc. Definitely an older shop (in business over 30 years) with a lot of older new/old baseball cards and nothing graded available or high end singles..mostly 1-20$ cards..alot of Kobe/Jordan older base cards available..he does have alot of inventory and cases to look through though!! We had a great tim

  4 months ago

• Eric Fain ★★★★★

  Love this small town card shop! Very friendly guys there and good prices. I stop by there everytime im in the area. I live 45 minutes away but still make the trip when I wanna find variety of cards.

  10 months ago

• Chris Bunn ★★★★★

  Did buisness here when I worked in Mount Sterling, great place, friendly and informative.

  7 months ago

• Pamela Sue Little ★

  1 star as haven't been in over 10 yrs lol about to try getting rid of quite a few cards found under storage a couple clocks with a card on eaxh... can't wait to see what customer is like alot of reviews were food

  a year ago

• ralph king ★★★★★

  Best card shop I've ever been to , I go there often and I've never done a review . No matter what you are looking for , low end to high end old or new , they have it . Prices are always competitive with the market and I always feel welcome and right at home. I look forward to my trips to mt sterling baseball cards and you should too. So yourself a favor and go visit.

  5 years ago

• Akers Academy ★★★★★

  This is the greatest place to buy sports cards! I went with my Dad this morning and I believe this is the perfect place for all your card needs! Cards are in great condition! This place includes everything from high priced singles to complete 2022 sets! The owner was great. He was incredibly helpful and very nice. He even gave me a free set of Topps trading cards! I look forward to visiting again for future baseball card purchases! You should come visit and purchase some cards! Tullian, age 9 Winchester, KY

  3 years ago

• David Hawkins ★

  Not willing to pull out the high end singles and the singles that are out are over double what they go for on eBay . My friend asked him if he has any nice joe burrow and he let us know anything nice if burrow goes straight to his personal collection after he beat around the bush about letting us see anything high end. Wouldn’t recommend buying singles unless you want to overpay and not get to look at really high end stuff for a personal collection, had plenty on packs was his best strength but would never buy a single that is double what it cost on eBay and the nicer stuff just gets put into

  3 years ago

• Jeff Woodard ★★★★★

  Great service. Competitively priced. Really friendly guy. This store has been here around 30 yrs. Shop and support our local businesses.

  3 years ago