Gilbert's Sports Nostalgia

Highlights

• ✨Vibe

  "Walking through the door here feels like walking into a treasure chest. Gary has an incredible collection of cards in every sport and is truly knowledgeable. He made me a great deal on a lot of cards and is clearly an inspiration to the local community of collectors. I will be back soon."

  — Mac Gostow

• 📚Selection

  "Great selection of cards and memorabilia. Owner has a true knowledge and passion for the hobby."

  — Kris R

• 🧠Staff

  "Great place and it all starts with the owner!"

  — Scott Katz

• 💵Prices

  "Walking through the door here feels like walking into a treasure chest. Gary has an incredible collection of cards in every sport and is truly knowledgeable. He made me a great deal on a lot of cards and is clearly an inspiration to the local community of collectors. I will be back soon."

  — Mac Gostow

Map

Hours

• Griffin Roy ★★★★★

  I live very close to his shop and visit quite often. My favorite sports shop that I’ve ever gone to. Gary (the owner) is such a nice guy and gives you very good deals. I highly recommend.

  10 months ago

• Stephen Sawyer ★

  This place is never open. Apparently they are bu appointment only. I'm assuming they do not sell anything new because they are appointment only. It must only be older stuff. More like a consignment store.

  4 months ago

• Mark M ★★★★★

  Maybe change your hours online save people the hassle of braving route 9 to go to your store. Gave 5 stars just so I could complain about the hours

  Edited 8 months ago

• Mac Gostow ★★★★★

  Walking through the door here feels like walking into a treasure chest. Gary has an incredible collection of cards in every sport and is truly knowledgeable. He made me a great deal on a lot of cards and is clearly an inspiration to the local community of collectors. I will be back soon.

  2 years ago

• Robert Bobobert ★★★★★

  I am always amazed how blessed we are to have this place in our lives.. been a long time customer with a homie typa feel to this gem. Basically can’t go wrong. Must check out and get involved. I will always have a place in my heart for this kind of thing and nobody I know can do it better than here. If you’re not into hobbies for some reason the owner is a true gentlemen with a heart of a gold steel alloy and is an amazing friend too. Pop in and see what’s in.. always great deals.

  5 years ago

• Mioline ★

  Would be nice if the hours said by appt only, instead of saying “open” and sitting in rte 9 traffic for nothing.

  a year ago

• Sam Dwyer ★★★★★

  This is a truly awesome place to be. Once you get there you see tons of autographs and memorabilia. They have well-priced baseball cards and packs. The owner is nice too. It's 5 points out of 5 points.

  10 years ago

• Elizabeth Wiggins ★★★★★

  Great place.Didn't have time to really shop like I wanted to but will be going back there soon.

  2 years ago