Card Shops Finder

Get Good Gaming Company

71 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

★★★★★ 4.7 · 83 reviews
PokémonMagic: The GatheringSports Cards 🏛️Vintage 🧠Expert staff

Highlights

  • Vibe

    "Taylor has been nothing less than a legend. Offers amazing prices and very honest with what market prices are and always happy to educate and drop knowledge with what’s new in the community."

    — Daniel Seo

  • 📚Selection

    "Taylor is great and they have a sweet selection of all things retro. Definitely worth a visit for collectors. Also they do TCG tournaments. Highly recommend"

    — SegaTron 64

  • 🧠Staff

    "Taylor is great and they have a sweet selection of all things retro. Definitely worth a visit for collectors. Also they do TCG tournaments. Highly recommend"

    — SegaTron 64

  • 💵Prices

    "Taylor has been nothing less than a legend. Offers amazing prices and very honest with what market prices are and always happy to educate and drop knowledge with what’s new in the community."

    — Daniel Seo

Map

Hours

Monday 12–7 PM
Tuesday 12–7 PM
Wednesday 12–7 PM
Thursday• today 12–7 PM
Friday 12–7 PM
Saturday 12–7 PM
Sunday 11 AM–4 PM

Recent reviews

8 of 83
  • Daniel Lopata ★★★★★

    I'm lucky I found this store a few years ago by accident. Taylor, the owner, is a very nice guy who knows his stuff. The store has a great collection of retro video games, consoles, pokémon and magic the gathering cards at great prices. If you're looking for something that he doesn't have Taylor will give you a call when he comes across it so that's been super helpful with finding rare games and collectibles.

    a year ago

  • TJ Del Reno ★★★★★

    I drove an hour just to sell my stuff to these guys. It was an extremely good price and they were super easy to work with. They were also a great hang while we wiped the consoles I brought. Wish I lived closer I would come and buy games from these dudes all the time.

    5 months ago

  • SegaTron 64 ★★★★★

    Taylor is great and they have a sweet selection of all things retro. Definitely worth a visit for collectors. Also they do TCG tournaments. Highly recommend

    7 months ago

  • DJ Broadhurst ★★★★★

    Absolutely amazing experience bought a ps4 today and it was a steal of a deal Taylor was so nice and helpful I will definitely be coming back in the future for future purchases Highly recommend 5 stars

    4 months ago

  • Tristan Nowak ★★

    I was about to drop quite a bit of $$$ here getting back into MTG, attitude lost the sales. Ignored when I walked in. You scoffed when I asked about vintage cards that you have posted, by you, on Google, and acted pretentious about new gameplay when I clearly stated I haven’t played in 20 years. Proceeded to cut me off and pickup the phone. Earned these stars bud. Would prefer to support you, thanks for the wasted drive and time. A little cx service goes a long way.

    6 months ago

  • Kingoshi ★★★★★

    Friendly staff. Great selection of games and at a good price. I just bought Need For Speed Most wanted for the OG Xbox that no other store around had. Also bought an RGA to HDMI converter they had. I’m definitely coming back for my next game purchase. They had games for pretty much every console. They also had a big selection of sports cards and pokemon as well.

    2 years ago

  • Daniel Seo ★★★★★

    Taylor has been nothing less than a legend. Offers amazing prices and very honest with what market prices are and always happy to educate and drop knowledge with what’s new in the community.

    7 months ago

  • Chase Reilly ★★★★★

    This place is awesome but the gentleman who runs the store is truly a class act. Top tier customer service. There’s not many gaming stores like this anymore and I’m so glad I stumbled across this gem. When we first walked in my son kept saying “I want a pikachu card” and after we checked out he handed my son a sleeved pikachu card and I just thought it was the nicest most thoughtful thing. I will definitely be returning and I look forward to recommending this place to others. ALSO everything is priced fairly and you don’t leave here feeling robbed. 10/10 experience.

    11 months ago

More shops near New City

3rd Universe Comic Emporium

35 N Riverside Ave, Croton-On-Hudson, NY 10520

★★★★★
4.7 · 258
PokémonMagic: The Gathering 🃏FNM

Piece of The Game

379 Tarrytown Rd, White Plains, NY 10607

★★★★★
4.7 · 147
PokémonSports Cards 📦Sealed product

The Baseball Card Store Inc

45 Prospect St, Midland Park, NJ 07432

★★★★★
4.5 · 179
PokémonSports Cards 🪑Play space

undiscovered Realm

66 Fulton St, White Plains, NY 10606

★★★★★
4.5 · 375
PokémonMagic: The Gathering 🪑Play space

CollectibleXchange

200 Corporate Blvd S # 120, Yonkers, NY 10701

★★★★★
2.3 · 12

American Legends

1107 Central Park Ave, Scarsdale, NY 10583

★★★★
4.2 · 121
PokémonSports Cards 😎Casual