Evolution Cards & Collectibles
164B Long Beach Rd, Island Park, NY 11558
Highlights
- ✨Vibe
"Friendly atmosphere very welcoming and honest crew."
— Nick Brigandi
- 📚Selection
"Nice place ....market prices. Nice selection."
— Anthony Campion
- 🧠Staff
"Owner is very cool, great trade night 👍"
— Chris Kim
- 💵Prices
"Nice place ....market prices. Nice selection."
— Anthony Campion
Map
Hours
| Monday | 1–7 PM |
| Tuesday | 1–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 1–7 PM |
| Thursday• today | 1–7 PM |
| Friday | 1–7 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–5 PM |
Recent reviews
8 of 243- Jennifer K ★★★★★
My son sent out cards here to get rated and the staff was super friendly And there was no pressure for sales. I’ve been in there probably ten times and have always been greeted and offered help but without the over your shoulder pressure . It’s a great store with events and rewards . I was upset reading the negative review someone left which is what made me write this . This store is 100% not someplace to expect fake cards and IF it ever happened I know they would fix it . Welcoming staff , highly recommend .
3 months ago
- Andrew Ludvigsen ★★★★★
I recently came across my old collection of Pokémon cards and decided to bring them to this store to see what they were worth. I did a little research beforehand, but it was a little overwhelming so I decided to bring the cards into a store and see what I could learn. The employee behind the counter could not have been nicer or more welcoming, they were easy to talk to and really made me feel at home. They took their time and meticulously went through all of my collection looking up cards that they thought were valuable and the entire way keeping me informed on how they do their homework and h
8 months ago
- John Accardi ★★★★★
Excellent store. Great people to deal with and very honest. I highly recommend coming to check out!!
2 months ago
- mike sannito ★★★★★
Evolution Cards & Collectibles is exactly what you want in a local card shop—honest, welcoming, and run the right way. Jesse is extremely knowledgeable and genuinely fair. He took his time going through everything with my 11-year-old son, explaining things clearly and treating him with real respect. He even struck a few deals with him on Pokémon cards, which absolutely made my son’s day. If you collect or you’ve got a kid who does, this is a must-visit business.
3 months ago
- Justin Abrams ★★★★★
Matt, you are the man. So kind to my young son and generous with purchase ready offers, knowledgeable and patient. Welcome to the community.
7 months ago
- Anthony Blaslov ★
Do not recommend buying pokemon packs from here. My son bought a singular new pack (for $20, which is crazy) and when he opened the outer layer, you could immediately tell that the pack inside had been opened and resealed. The pack wrapping was warped and the seal was clearly misaligned. I should have told him to not open it so we could return it, but he was so excited he couldn't wait. I also heard there were a lot of other kids in the store buying items, so please make sure what your children are buying is real and they are getting a fair price. They did have a lot of loose cards decently pr
6 months ago
- Michelle “Mich” Ferraino ★★★★★
Very extensive collection, Frank is very knowledgeable and willing to work with people. Good community events as well! We will be back.
3 months ago
- Joe Cambridge ★★★★★
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Highly recommended! Amazing card store with a killer selection of sports and Pokémon cards—vintage to new, all fairly priced. The staff are super friendly and crazy knowledgeable. Welcoming vibe, great events, and top-notch service. A must-visit!
a year ago
More shops near Island Park
DZCollectibles Long Island
2833 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572
Living Legends Memorabilia and Collectibles, Inc.
124 S Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11570