BMW Sportscards
555 D'onofrio Dr Suite 103, Madison, WI 53719
Highlights
- ✨Vibe
"Friendly and fast service. Honest business."
— Alexa Bardho
- 📚Selection
"Service is great. Brian is easy to work with and good selection overall"
— Luke Rhyner
- 🧠Staff
"Really nice place. Knowledgeable conversation"
— Adam Pasbrig
- 🎟️Events
"Staff even gave me a free Prizm Draft Picks Cello. Check out BMW especially for vintage card consignment- that's their specialty."
— Dean Fuchsia
- 💵Prices
"brian paid me a great price for my stuff"
— Tearney Schultz
Map
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–2 PM |
| Thursday• today | 12–2 PM |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Recent reviews
8 of 2,747- Greg Kebbekus ★★★★★
Brian is a friendly and extremely knowledgeable guy to take your sports memorabilia, plus just about anything else you can think of, to have it evaluated. Brian will look everything over while you wait and entertain you along the way. He gave us very fair prices and we didn't have to take anything back home! Very clean bathroom too.
5 months ago
- I B (BRAVO) ★★★★★
I stopped in recently and the customer service was great. Brian and I had a great talk. He is very knowledgeable. Thank you much!
4 months ago
- Ronald Rode ★★★★★
What a wonderful experience, Brian, the B in BMW Sportscards, showed my Grandkids,aged 12 and 6, the different types and styles of cards.So patient and super friendly. We will be regular patrons! It made our weekend special. Thank you.
4 months ago
- BBB82 ★★★★★
Took a little time talked it over we both came to an agreement was very fair very nice person Brian is his name if you got something to sell that sports or coins this is the guy to go to very nice guy if there were 10 Stars I'd give 10 Stars so I got to go five stars times 2...
6 months ago
- David Pacha ★★★★★
My history with Brian goes back over 30 years-when he meticulously helped guide me to the Rosemont Convention Center ( being from Iowa and no GPS yet) this was in itself a huge kindness. From the first time we met where he helped me put back together my childhood Philadelphia football sets, to a conversation just today 9/19/25- Brian has been absolutely the best. Knowledgeable, friendly and very personable. I have never had a bad experience with him and nor should anyone else. Thanks again, Brian!!
8 months ago
- Darin Fuhro ★★★★★
This shop is awesome. Brian is great and offers great conversations while shopping. Great chance to find some great items as well. If you are in the area, this is a must stop! Overly fair on pricing!
3 years ago
- JP Heim ★★★★★
What an unexpectedly fantastic experience. In town for a business trip, found BMW located nearby and had to check them out. Located in an office park building, BMW is an unassuming haven for sports collectors and hobbyists. Offering items from all decades, there is sure to be something for everyone. From vintage (by request), to early 90's, and modern stars, there are sports card singles, sets, and some wax. The experience... Met at the front entrance by the owner, Brian, we proceeded to a suite full of sports cards and sports collectibles. But be forewarned, don't expect to see the items n
3 years ago
- keng yang ★★★★★
Brian was very nice and helpful, Great experience! Would definitely come back!
3 months ago
More shops near Madison
Westfield Comics - West
7475 Mineral Point Rd #22, Madison, WI 53717
Mox Mania, LLC
410 D'onofrio Dr, Madison, WI 53719
Slab Factory - Sports & Trading Cards
739 N High Point Rd, Madison, WI 53717